Click here to see the all winners. I have also posted it below and linked, where applicable, to my reviews. Also, don’t forget I have this permanent page which archives all the horror and horror-esque awards. Use that page to find backlist winners too. They all make great sure bet horror suggestions.
Every book listed here is a great option to add to any public library collection. I have read all or part of every single title listed here [except Looming Low].
Finally, check out my popular post Using Awards Lists As A RA Tool for more advice.